Dateline NBC Righteous Obsession Airs January 4 2025 on NBC

This Saturday, January 4, 2025, at 8:00 p.m. ET/7:00 p.m. CT, Dateline presents Righteous Obsession, a two-hour special that dives deep into the investigation of a deadly home invasion involving business owner Milton Sawyer. What seemed to be a straightforward robbery quickly takes a shocking turn when an unexpected witness, located on the other side of the country, comes forward with crucial information.

Correspondent Dennis Murphy reports on this dark and twisted tale of lust, obsession, and manipulation. The investigation, which initially focused on a break-in gone wrong, reveals deeper secrets as detectives uncover a web of deception that would ultimately lead to a murder. This special features exclusive interviews and never-before-seen police footage that bring new details to light and offer a comprehensive look at how this complex case unfolded.

Dateline interviews key figures including Milton’s son Caleb Sawyer, Oregon dairy farmer and former Youth Pastor Louie Kazemier, and Pasquotank County investigator Major Aaron Wallio, who all share their insights into the case. The investigation leads to a gripping narrative that reveals how a mix of obsession and manipulation ultimately changed the course of several lives.

Don’t miss this emotional and captivating Dateline special as it uncovers the chilling truth behind a murder in Elizabeth City, North Carolina.